There's been a lot of talk about breastfeeding lately, and while I'm not generally one to hop on the bandwagon, it's spurring me on to actually sit down and write the post I've been meaning to write for quite a long time now. About a year, in fact. (Oh, hello, why yes, I DO still call myself a blogger, why do you ask?)
It's not a post about the things that are being talked about, though. It's not about covering up or not, not about breast vs formula or about the marketing of formula, though that irks me plenty. It's not about a woman's right to feed anywhere or her need for support. It's simply about my journey through the narrows of trying to feed, how I found myself where I ended up, and how something that has been called heroic on occasion really wasn't, not to my mind, it was just my own haphazard solution to a feeding method I felt was workable for me.
I always intended to breastfeed. It was an intellectual decision for me, because I knew the many reasons why breast was best, but I will say this here: it was not something I felt comfortable with. It was something I hoped I would become comfortable with, would just get used to be virtue of sheer need and repetition, but it was not something I was into.
I am not a touchy person. I am not huggy. I do not kiss my family. hugs and kisses and spontaneous "I love you's" were not part of my family, not a feature of my upbringing. I don't mean to suggest that my family was cold, not by a long way. It's just that affection was shown in other ways. By dancing, singing and playing music together, by sharing a story, eating meals together, and always, always saying goodnight. I never came home to a sleeping house, not once. Love was woven into the fabric of the clothes my mother made for me by hand, baked into the crusts of the quiches she made for dinner, knowing they were my favourite, sketched into the lies of pictures drawn both of and for me, and pressed into homemade peanut-butter cookies with the fork she helped me hold while I pushed crosshatches into their flour-dusted surfaces. But hugs and cuddles, no.
I am used to seeing my body as my own. I have shared it with precious few people in my life, and had only, until I hit the week before birth, been examined by one doctor in my life. All this to say, I was not comfortable with the sharing of my body over and over on demand, but yes, I planned to try and get there.
With Pumpkinpie, weeks and weeks of trying and crying, feeding by various alternates while avoiding the bottle, visiting consultants and clinics failed to result in a child who could latch. Finally, after pumping her meals for some 5 or 6 weeks anyhow, I pleaded with my doctor. If I continue to pump, is it just as good if I feed her breastmilk from a bottle? I coudn't see how I could keep going much longer how I was. She gave me the okay, as long as I was holding Pumpkinpie, so we still go the bonding time as she fed. I would have done that anyhow. It seemed like a wonderful deal to me, to be able to stop putting myself through the wringer. A bargain, in fact.
And so that is what I did - I pumped. It was easy for me, really. I got a rhythm going with Pumpkinpie's naps and my pumping, bought a good pump, and set us up with bottles. It was a pain sometimes, to be sure, but it also allowed some freedoms - I could let Misterpie take a feeding in the evening while I caught up on a little sleep, or go out for a little while now and then, not being physically tethered to my wee babe. I eventually started to suffer from a little fatigue, around about month 10, but by then, it seemed like it was worth it to stick to my commitment to pump for just shy of a year. I had come so far already, and I am stubborn when I make a promise, so I was going to stick it out. At that point, why not?
With The Bun, I was mostly overwhelmed with the pain. I decided on a half-and-half solution, which worked well for a few weeks, and I was a happy mama. I had it all, the perfect combination of portability with breastfeeding and the freedom of bottles. It was strange for me, the breastfeeding, but I wanted it to work, and was determined to keep it up until it felt normal. Until the nipping starting. Once I could not stop the wee Bun from letting go slightly and chomping down hard on the end of my poor battered nipple, I was done. This was not the kind of pain that I could mitigate with lanolin or an extra session of pumping, and it didn't seem to be stopping, so I did. Once again, a good 6 weeks or so in, I turned to my trusty pump for feeding, and didn't look back.
It was even easier the second time, knowing that I had and could again manage this for a year. The year went faster. By the end, I was happy to hang up the pump, but hadn't even felt the same kind of drudge-y feeling that I had had before, maybe because I was better at moderating my pumping to The Bun's appetites, wasn't as rigourously scheduled as I had been with Pumpkinpie, when I didn't know better and was terrified of not having enough. (Which now seems absurd, since I now know I had way more than I even needed, and didn't have to worry.)
I have had people tell me this is medal-worthy. Truly? I don't think so. It wasn't about being a martyr, it wasn't even really hard. I know people who toughed it out through incredible pain for weeks on end, and to be totally honest, it feels to me liked I wimped out by comparison, because I just wasn't prepared to deal prolonged torture. (You think torture is an exaggeration? how well do you think it would go over if they started using alligator clamps on the nipples of Guantanamo detainees? Really, it fucking hurts.)
It was instead, quite simply, my answer to the question that dogs every mom with a new baby - how to best feed it. It worked for me in striking the balance between discomfort, lack of success, and painful starts versus the desire to give my babes the best I could. I don't think less of other people if formula is their answer, but I knew that I could give breast milk without too onerous an effort, so it didn't sit well with me to ignore that natural bounty in favour of something created.
We are also fortunate in Canada to have a full year off. In both cases, I stopped before returning to work, weaning my babes onto milk in time to return to work without issues of leaking, swollen breasts, without a pump or a nursing bra. had I lived in the States? There is no way I would have lasted a year. But for me, this worked. Between what I wanted to give and what I felt I could handle for myself, it was the right point on the continuum.
So for me? My pump was best - my best friend, my partner in feeding my babies the best I could. If anyone needs a medal around here, she lives in a discreet little black faux-leather carrying case.
Labels: Baby Bun, moi, parenting dilemmas, Pumpkinpie